I Would Die for That
I got myself in some trouble on a message board tonight… a woman posted a question on an infertility board asking if it bothered others when they see children at the RE’s office. I’ve seen this topic so many times, and it seems that a lot (not all) of IFers (read: infertiles) with no children think that they should be protected from seeing children when they go to the REs office.
Now I understand and respect the pain of dealing with infertility and seeing a child, especially a baby. I selfishly quit taking Calista to her playgroup when the other moms all started getting pregnant with their second — and later third — children and we were struggling to get pregnant again. Every playgroup seemed to be pregnant or new moms talking pregnancy, babies, etc… and it just became to be too much for me. There were accidental pregnancies, planned pregnancies and even a pregnancy after a thought-to-be lost battle with infertility. And no matter how happy I was for these women, my own pain trumped that happiness and I cried inside for what we could not have.
So yes, I understand the pain that pregnant women or babies can bring when you’re fighting your own demons brought about by infertility. However, I have never understood this logic that some women have that the REs office should be devoid of children. First of all, the REs job is to bring children into the world! To me, an REs office with no children almost seems counterintuitive.
Second, the women at the office don’t bring their children because it’s a fun thing to do. It’s never fun to try to keep your 2 year old by your head while you’re pantsless on the table, legs in the stirrups and a dildo cam (that’s a transvaginal ultrasound wand) in the hoo-haa. I can think of a hundred other things I’d rather do than try to explain these things to my daughter, but sometimes, you do what you have to do, even if it means bringing your young child to the REs office.
As for the women in the waiting room who have no children, I would sincerely hope that they could view my (or someone else’s) child as hope — hope they they, too, will overcome infertility. I would also hope that they would realize that I’m not there to rub my kid in someone’s face. Like them, I am there with a heart full of hopes and dreams, hoping to leave with a uterus full of hopes and dreams. No, we are not the same, because I have a child and she doesn’t, but realize it or not, I do feel her pain.
But strangely, she can’t accept that I feel her pain. So many childless women think that having a child is the “cure” for the pain of infertility. Sure, in the beginning, it is. The immense joy and love you feel for your son or daughter takes away the years of heartache and invasive procedures. But soon, for most, comes the time when the longing for another arises from within and you find yourself yearning for another child. And in my experience, the second time around was worse. Not only because we had to endure so much more to get pregnant, but because I’d been there. I’d been pregnant, I’d given birth, I’d held my newborn. This time, I wasn’t just longing for a child, I knew what I would be missing out on if it didn’t happen again.
It’s like wanting to go to Paris (or wherever you want to go) in a way. If you’ve never been there, you dream, you imagine and you long to go. And then, one day, you get to go and it’s a thousand times better than you ever imagined!! You return home and for a while, you feel content. But soon, you start to long to return, and this time, it’s not all just dreams. You know what waits for you and you desperately try to find a way to go back. You remember the sights, the sounds and the smells of that amazing trip but it remains just out of your reach. It’s the same with a child.
Not only do you hold the sweet memories of bringing that child into the world, but sometimes — as was our case — that child is old enough to start asking for a sibling. I can’t tell you how many times I fought back the tears when Calista would talk about her “baby sister” she was going to have and all the things they’d do together.
I never imagined I’d have to face the possibility of not having a child as I had to when we first found out about our issues back in 2002 when trying to have our first. And then, once she was here, it never dawned on me that I might not have another… that she might not have a sibling.
The idea of not having a child is a scary, heartbreaking thought. And the idea of not being able to give your child a sibling, to not have another child, to imagine your child’s life when you are gone and they have no brothers or sisters when that has never been part of your plan is just as scary. Explaining to your three year-old that there may never be a baby in Mommy’s tummy is a talk you never hope to have, yet one day, you find yourself searching for the words that your little one might understand somehow.
Infertility is heartbreaking for anyone who suffers. Whether you’re the mom who has never been pregnant, the mom who has lost several pregnancies, the mom trying for a second or the mom trying for a fourth… your heart is broken, a tiny piece missing. A piece you fear you may never find.
I admit, when we were still trying to conceive our first child, I didn’t “get it”. I didn’t understand how someone with a child could hurt so much because, after all, they had a child. I am also glad to say I never chastised those women or devalued their pain in any way. I never understood how they could feel the pain that I did, but we all feel things differently, and until I’ve walked in someone else’s shoes, I cannot judge.
Sadly, I was later forced to walk in those shoes. I no longer question the pain a mother feels when she cannot have another child for whatever reason. I know that a mother — whether childless or with ten children — is a mother in her heart and without her children, there will be pain. The pain may change, but it’s there nonetheless.
I found infertility after having a child to be one of the saddest, loneliest times in my life. Many infertility message boards are primarily made up of those with no children. They require you to put disclaimers in your posts if you are going to mention a child, a pregnancy or a pregnancy loss. I quickly learned not to even mention I had a child if I wanted true support. On message boards with signatures, I refrain from posting Calista’s name or picture and remove my signature entirely if replying to someone who is not yet pregnant so they don’t see my pregnancy ticker and feel hurt.
As for “the real world”, few people really understood that there could be pain in infertility if you already have a child. You get told that you should be glad you have a child. And yes, you should — you ALWAYS should — and we are eternally grateful for Calista. But it doesn’t make you hurt any less, unfortunately. All you do is start to feel guilty for your pain and then you feel forced to hide it. You become afraid to talk to people at all, and you become isolated.
Thankfully, I have many friends online who have loved and supported me through it all, and honestly, I couldn’t imagine what it would have been like without the support of these friends (and some strangers, too). I pity those who truly don’t have anyone to reach out to in their struggles.
As for the battle between the infertile with no children versus the infertile with at least once child, it’s sad that we can’t just support each other unconditionally. But infertility is a vile, jealous affliction that truly changes us and alters our perceptions for an indefinite amount of time. I’ve seen women post that they “hate” pregnant women… yet they long to be one. Hopefully, no matter who we are, we will all reach the other side a better woman, a mother and friends.
I came across this video tonight that someone had posted on an infertility message board I visit. It’s called “I Would Die for That” and it’s really touching. Whether you long for your first or your fifth child, this video will move you. You can see it at: http://www.youtube.com/v/JqfGqOx2iDQ
To anyone who may be reading who still longs for their first… I understand your pain. I hope that you will accept that thought I am different, and though you may think I have all that you need to make yourself whole, I have pain, too. We are, unfortunately, in this together.

Great Post Sommer!
Well said. I understand both sides. My husband and I had tried for our first for 4 years. We went through IVF, 5 IUI’s and countless tests to get her. I recall seeing a woman come into our RE’s office with twins once before we had gotten pregnant. The woman leaned over and whispered “IVF”. I remember feeling hopeful…not resentful. I thought…maybe this WILL work.
Later after our first was born (IVF) I took her to our RE’s office when we were going through IVF again. Not because I wanted to, but because anyone who has been through IVF knows you are at the office so much that sometimes you just can’t find care for you child while you go to a Dr. appointment 3x a week.
I never intended to hurt anyone. I just wanted to have another child…
But, I know that it hurts…not that you are unhappy that someone else is pregnant…it’s just a deep hurt you feel that YOU cannot get pregnant. I can’t tell you how many times I have cried over infertility. I still do. I don’t think I will ever get over it. The pain was just so much. I have 2 daughters now, but I think the years of heartache is burned into my memory.
I always thought of children in the RE’s waiting room as proof that the doctor’s methods worked. I didn’t know if that child was produced from this RE’s work or not, but I assumed s/he was. It gave me hope that I could be that woman one day.
Sommer – that is so well put – I had tears in my eyes reading it and the video – OMG I can’t stop the tears. All the feelings of trying for so long to have our miracle came flooding back.
You are an inspiration to so many people – and I thank you for being who you are.
Sommer, this is eloquent. Thanks for the insight.
Sommer,
Very nicely written. I know the pain of longing and wanting. I went through hell to have my first and then my second. I would really love another but I am not ready to ride that roller coaster. I do know the pain when seeing a pregnant mom, and wish it was me. But I am not getting the point of being able to enjoy what I have been blessed with and celebrate with them.
Thanks for putting this all in writing.
Kelly
Struggling with primary IF and many other issues, I have learned that:
When we are struggling with something,
it is NOT “the situation” what really bothers and affects us….
it is MUCH more the way we react to it what really does!!!
I believe it doesn’t matter if it’s primary or secondary IF, it hurts!!!… And for me, even though it is not easy, I prefer to see in every child, IN EVERY PLACE I GO, a bright promise of HOPE… Hopefully someday will be my turn! :)
Very well put. I hope that we ladies can start to understand each other a little better in this journey. Posts like this are a firm step in that direction.
Wow, what a powerful song! We struggled with infertility for 3 years before having our precious son and I can empathize with the emotions she sings about.
Sommer- I want to thank you for writing what you did- I think that really untill you walk in “our” shoes, you dont understand infertility fully- I know I didnt- I thought after my first m/c it was just a one time thing- then I lost my son– I was suddenly in another world, thrown there by God’s hand for what ever reason- I cant change it, I cant go back- all I can do is move forward try my best to be happy for everyone I see with children, be thankfull those that have gone through infertility and had success and share their story so I can know that in the future I have hope also– does that make sense?
It doesnt matter where I see a child, infant at I hurt no matter what– but I know that they are God’s gift and maybe just maybe one day it will be my turn.
God bless you and everone that reads your board- you are a true example of strength and hope. I cant wait to see your babies.
Thank you also for allowing so many people to share this great joy with you :-)
Denise
Nicely put. I like the Paris analogy, a very tangible explination.
Sommer, I hope you dont mind but I quoted part of your blog on a message board I help run. I think you explained secondary infertility PERFECTLY…I have never heard someone explain it like that.
Just hit close to home because I went through the same when we ttc #2
I think this was well written.
When we were ttc #3 after getting pregnant the first two times very easily, I got a glimpse into the world of those struggling with infertility. We were fortunate to be able to get pregnant after 18 months and fertility meds, but I understand the pain you feel when going through infertility, whether it be the first or tenth time.
This is what I told those who didn’t understand how I could hurt when I was lucky enough to have two healthy children. I compared it to eyesight (not the same thing at all, but it worked)– Is it harder to be born blind and never experience the sights of the world and the gift of vision or to have experienced all there is to see and then have that gift taken away from you, and never be able to see again?
That seemed to help some better understand that no matter what stage your family is, infertility affects everyone.
Good luck to you!
Christina
Sommer,
You are awesome! Thank you for mentioning the pain of those who can get pregnant but, for whatever reason, are unable to maintain a pregnancy. After our third loss, DH and I began seeing the RE for the treatment of recurrent miscarriage. Our insurance company informed us that they would not cover the visits because we did not meet their definition of an infertile couple. I was irate! Two-and-a-half years of TTC with no living baby should justify our trips to the RE, right? Evidently not. Fortunately, the RE’s office worked things out with the insurance company, but talk about adding salt to my wound! Not being able to have a baby is PAINFUL, regardless of the circumstances.
Bravo! I also felt hope on seeing babies prior to Zoe’s conception. She did it for them, she can make it happen for us . . .
And now, as I am faced with dragging Zoe to the RE one more time on Thursday for an injectible class, I see this thread.
Sigh.
Everything you just wrote—>thank you! You’ve just summed up what I’ve been feeling lately. The other day at the RE’s there was a little girl with her mom and I truly hope that the couples waiting saw it as hope. If not, why even be there. It’s what we all aspire to have, even if for some, it means getting it a different way.
I have 2 children who I watch over and 4 who watch over me. Does that mean I shouldn’t or don’t have a right to want more children. It really is a double edge sword. I don’t fit in with my TTC/preggo friends and I don’t really fit in with my infertile friends. I scare the ttc/preggos and anger the IF’s.
It would be great if we could all be part of one sisterhood regardless of the circumstances that brought us there.
I have that video on my blog and am so glad it is gaining attention.